Ed Young announced last week that Fellowship Church has opened a new satellite church in Columbia, South Carolina - just 1/2 mile from Perry Noble's Columbia satellite church! Ed Young's new Columbia satellite is actually an acquisition of an existing church (Friend Church) that is joining Ed Young's system of churches. Ed did the same thing in Miami last month, acquiring a former hispanic baptist in Midtown Miami. These acquisitions are a perfect business strategy for Ed: each of these new churches will be a place where he can sell his books and sermons, and where revenue can be brought back to the mother church.
Seeing Ed Young expand his church brand into South Carolina should not come as a surprise, given that Perry Noble has seen explosive growth with his satellites with revenue in excess of $25 million a year. There are plenty of peeps in South Carolina ready to join mega churches,and who are gullible enough to obey Noble's and Young's abusive tithing sermons (for sampling, click here, here, here, here, here, and here)
The continued expansion of mega churches using satellites and church acquisitions is further proof that modern evangelicalism is about mega church personalities who are seeking to build their personal and church brands by expanding into areas already saturated with churches to tap into wealthy markets.
This reminds me of this quote by SBC pastor Bart Barber that I featured on my blog last year:
"I predict that you won't soon see the following multi-campus sites opening: Fellowship Church Wilmer-Hutchins Campus, Saddleback Watts Campus, NorthPoint Community Church Bankhead Campus, or Second Baptist Houston Third-Ward Campus. The multi-site movement and the preponderance of domestic SBC church planting is focused like a laser upon those areas where people with lots of money live in church-friendly cultures—places where it is easy to fill a church with rich people." Bart Barber, Pastor FBC Farmersville (TX)Bart is right on the money; Ed Young is a Southern Baptist, and he is expanding into areas where he can get new church members who have loads of money who just might be willing to give Ed their checking account numbers.
Recently, Pastor Tom Messer of Trinity Baptist Church in Jacksonville announced the church's plans to open a new satellite church in affluent St. John's county, just south of Jacksonville. Messer told his congregation how much it would cost, who would pay for it, and how the initial investment will yield positive dividends.
Said Tom Messer in Trinity's evening service on September 16, 2012:"Look, its going to take us probably $150,000 in a budget and $150,000 in capital investment to start a South Campus. About $300,000. You say 'where is that money going to come from?' You. You say 'Really? We're going to give it to all those people down there in St. John's county?' Yes! You say 'Will they ever give it back?' Sure. Absolutely. They're going to invest it in YOUR rescue mission, they're going to invest it in YOUR college...". Pastor Tom Messer, 9/16/12
That quote is very telling, and gives us a glimpse into how pastors view satellites! The satellite church members are viewed as people that can give money that will come back to the mother church to the benefit of the church members!
That is the modern model of mega church growth. Potential new church members are viewed as a market to be tapped. Potential church members are viewed as "giving units" who can begin generating positive cash flow to the mother church. Starting new, autonomous churches doesn't generate cash flow for the mother church, doesn't help hire new staff, or provide the needed revenue to justify an increase in the pastor's salary and expense budget.
It will be interesting to watch the battle of Perry Noble and Ed Young in Columbia. Reminds me of this video, where Will Ferrell and Jimmy Fallon quarrel over who has the tightest pants in the land.
In Malachi 3 they were needing a revival. In Malachi 3, God says here's how you can have one. "Bring your tithes and offerings and I will cause revival to come." They needed revival and He said "you have robbed from Me, but if you will bring your tithes and offerings, "and I'm paraphrasing, " revival will break out again." How many of you know there's a connection here folks. Tithing is God's way of bringing a move of God in the Earth. I am convinced that the church wants revival. He said bring your tithes and offerings to the storehouse. And He said "when you bring your tithes and offerings, I'm going to release myself in the Earth". Now what would happen if the church and America started to do that, what would we have in America? Revival...a return to faith and faithfullness in God. I can tell you what we would have, if every Christian in America got on their knees and said "Father, forgive me for stealing from You, I didn't realize it was a sacred thing" and say "I will obey You, I will become a tither." I can tell you there would be a Holy Ghost move in this nation. We would call the shots. We could vote in who we wanted.
ReplyDeleteAs the Apostle Paul says in 1 Corinthians 3 "But their minds were made dull, for to this day the same veil remains when the old covenant is read. It has not been removed, because only in Christ is it taken away. Even to this day when Moses is read, a veil covers their hearts."
ReplyDeleteThose who preach tithing and those who hear it have a veil lover their hearts. You cannot fully know Christ if you are still tied to the old covenant laws which are no longer in effect. Don't let any of these suave preachers fool you! They are holding you captive to a law which is no longer binding on Christians.
Troll is out early this morning! The OT tithe was never money - it was food - a tenth of your fields and tenth of your herds. The only time "tithe" is mentioned in the new testament is when Jesus tells the Pharisees that they tithe their dill and cumin - foodstuff! A 501(c)3 wants me to "tithe"? Certainly, it'll have to be in a year when my garden grows in!
ReplyDeleteAnon - Malachi was accusing the priests of robbing God of the tithe the people were bringing. Only Levites could collect tithes, we don't have them any more. Plus, at that time, there was a NATION of Israel, that had ONE temple where God supposedly dwelt and the nation had an actual storehouse where food was to be kept. You have been deeply abused to think that the loving Creator God wants you to give your hard earned money, money he enabled you to earn, to some 501(c)(3) to pay salaries, utilities, overhead, and have nice programs for Christians to come to once or twice a week.
ReplyDeleteThink about it. The Creator, invisible God's plan is for you to fork over your income to some guy's budget? Really? What a great scam if you can get people to believe it.
Have you ever read the New Testament? You are talking to Christians and not orthodox Jews are you not?
That is OT thinking, not NT practice. If more people tithed here in the U.S., there would be more million dollar preachers in multi-million dollar homes and Krystal Kathydrals for them to fleece the flock in. Look at the churches in the U.S. with big facilities. They do not spend their money on helping the poor and downtrodden, the sort of people Jesus served. NO. They pay big benefits to the staff, have comfy places to sit while being entertained, and go to work aiding and abetting the rich who steal from the poor.
ReplyDeleteThe heart of the first comment can be expressed in his closing remarks: "WE would call the shots. WE could vote in who WE wanted." WOW! Did this person just say that? I would rather have JESUS call the shots and vote in who HE wanted. In fact, HE already does due to HIS sovereignty.
ReplyDeleteTo answer the other question (i.e. What would happen if every church attender tithed?) Well, my guess is that you would see the hiring of more pastors and the building of bigger buildings. Tithe teaching pastors are quick to state that if you aren't tithing on a little, then you will not on much. I would like to see them turn this judgement on themselves. If they are spending all of their donations on themselves with the "little" that they receive, then they will spend it all on themselves if they get more.
I am surprised that Baptists have not asked/canvassed/lobbied the Government to collect the payroll tax of 10% as the Germans are doing (it is only 9% for the Germans).
ReplyDeleteBack on topic: WHY do you think these churches, Trinity included, are "called" to open campuses in affluent markets? Just more PROOF that as "Godly" as men like Tom Messer may appear to be, they are all about the money. Unbelievable and sickening! And yet their congregants are getting what they pay for, so no objections. And besides, the poor will get pennies on the dollar too. So its a win-win. 1 penny on the dollar is better than nothing, right orphan/widow/poor?
ReplyDeleteHmmm. Let me guess, preacher. Your religion teaches there is an invisible being that wants me to give you my money. Yeah, I'll buy that. No problem with that at all. Who do I make the check to? Wait, I can give online to this invisible being? How convenient! What a great God this is. I thought it said to bring the tithe, not send it online. And wait, there is more? He will treat me better if I do that? No favoritism? Sounds good. I give Him (by giving to you), money I earn by working hard (its his money when my boss has it, and his money after I work all day for it and my boss gives His money to me in exchange for my labor;) but I go ahead and give it back to my boss, no I mean God, oops I mean to my church because this is what the ancient Jews did to the Levitical tribe of priests in ancient days with food. Mskrd sense to me. I am sure it is Biblical if you say so. I mean what motive would you have to mislead me and lie to me about this. It's not like your salary and support of your family depends on it. I am sure your degree in Old Testament history or preaching would make you employable anywhere. So where can I sign up? I want to be a Christian and start giving God his money back asap. :)
ReplyDeleteListen, God doesn't need your money. Can I tell you something, God doesn't need your money. This isn't about God needing your money or my money. I mean if you have to think about this, would you just think about where He lives, and tell me He needs my little tithe. This tithe isn't about God needing my money, . it's about my relationship to Him. Its about involving me in the dynamics of a great Kingdom in the earth where there will be no decrease, always an increase in the Kingdom. Thats what this is all about. Its not about God needing my money. I mean He could throw down a chunk of gold anytime. And to think that God's concerned about my ten percent. God said "Listen, I want to see if I can trust you. I want you to take what is sacred and see what you do with it, so I can give you something bigger and better ." That's what its all about.
ReplyDeleteTithing involves your whole heart...your attitude and motive.
Old testament laws cannot bring revival to new testament believers. Oh ye foolish Americans, who has deceived you that you should not obey the truth? You who were saved by grace are you now going to get God to send revival through the works of the law?
ReplyDeleteI have a bit of a problem with preachers who take their "executive staff" to Disney Land and use their experience in a serman as Mac Brunson did - the budget at FBC is so misused - people see it and have no desire to see their tithe moneies going to these big cats for pleasure!
ReplyDeleteWhat sermon transcript are some of these posts from?
ReplyDeleteDog this is a funny post.
ReplyDeleteAnonymous 2:23pm
ReplyDelete"That's what tithing's all about, Charlie Brown!"
No, that's not what tithing is all about. Tithing under the law was supporting the Levitical priests with food - no money. They were provided with food because they did not have any inheritance of land in Israel. No land means no place to grow your own. God was their inheritance. As such, the other tribes in Israel supported the priests. The modern custom of tithing is so far from the OT truth of it. And what's worse, these preachers are twisting it for THEIR gain, not for the kingdom, and gullible followers who are too lazy to open their bibles and read for themselves are repeating these same lies. As followers of Christ, our salvation comes from grace, not from the works of the law. Even if we were still under the law, the tithe would not apply - there is no Levitical priesthood today.
What would happen to the church in America if every Christian who claims to be tithing, would start treating their tithes as a sacred thing? What would happen to the church in America if every Christian started to tithe? I can tell you. We would annihilate welfare. Folks would line up at the church to get help, not at some office downtown. And what an opportunity for the Gospel. Missionaries wouldn't be calling to say "My son's hungry, please send me some food." Some 20 percent of Christians in typical churches are tithers. In the first church that I attended, I knew a man that was rich, the wealthiest man there - had more money than he could spend in his lifetime - he came up to me and said "I gave $5.00 a week and that's all I will ever give." Now I bet you he's sorry about that.
ReplyDeleteHe's dead. I kind of think when he got to heaven, God said "Did you bring your $5.00 with you?" He didn't understand what was holy and unholy. He was just tight-fisted and stingy. Thats what he was. He loved money. That's not giving to God. A church that understands that the tithe is a holy, sacred thing will prosper and grow. We have to come to understand, that I'm not giving my tithe, it is not my tithe, it's HIS tithe and it is the Pastors responsiblity to God to see that it gets to the right place.
Tight pants?
ReplyDeleteIs it godly to mock? Being a smart alec does not make You spiritual
God is tired of this mess. He does not want His kids hating each other.
Blogs like this will one day burn in Hell.
Is it godly to mock? Being a smart alec does not make You spiritual
ReplyDeleteYou might want to post that comment over here: http://pastorfashion.com/ as Ed Young does his own bit of mocking of fashion in a video.
I might be wrong but wasn't old testament tithing a temple tax?
ReplyDeleteAren't we under a new covenant?
Shouldn't true revival be about repntance and salvation?
Is this a serious blog?
ReplyDeleteIt seems taht most of the stuff on here is satire. I love good humor but when it is at the expense of other Christians, it borders on self-righteousness.
I smell a Pharisee here.
Even Jesus used sarcasm to illustrate a point. Of course the trolls here want to point at the messenger instead of defending the antics of these preachers.
ReplyDeleteOk, I apologize in advance for once again feeding the troll.
ReplyDelete“Is it godly to mock? Being a smart alec does not make You spiritual”
You mean like Elijah? 1 Kings 18:27 “And at Noon Elijah mocked them…”
“God is tired of this mess. He does not want His kids hating each other.”
Really? Does God consult with you? Or is it just you that is tired of this mess? Of course coming here is entirely voluntary on your part. If you do not like what is posted here you should follow the advice of those you admire so much and in their words, “If you don’t like it, leave.
“Blogs like this will one day burn in Hell.”
On this one I have to admit you are partly right. Blogs like this will burn one day, just not in hell. Like everything else that is man made everything here is going to burn. Only people will carry on into eternity.
Here is a great teaching on tithing:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.amazon.com/Tithing-Nailed-To-The-Cross/dp/1456758071/ref=pd_sim_sbs_b_7
What would happen to the church in America if every Christian who claims to be tithing, would start treating their tithes as a sacred thing? What would happen to the church in America if every Christian started to tithe?
ReplyDelete___________________________________
Here is what would happen: Pastors buying more air time on TV, opening of satellite churches in affluent areas, hiring family members on staff, building even larger extravagant churches (maybe even some Cathedrals with gold plated idols would make a rebound?), luxury cruises, multiple trips year after year after year to the "holy" land, private jets, more christian schools for our little angels, less money for government to really hire police and teachers and maintain schools, more poor and homeless because generous Christians are giving any and all extra income they have to the church, more cities and governments cutting libraries and parks because the revenue is down due to tax exempt organizations siphoning off millions and millions from the citizens into a "non-profit" organization that doesn't pay taxes on its wealth. Should I go on? If you really think members giving more would help the poor more, then why do so many churches have capital campaigns and building programs, but none are raising these funds to help the poor. Sheesh! Please quit living in la la land.
Don't start new churches. Don't give to the church. Don't listen to the pastor. Don't tithe to your church. Don't wear certain type of clothing while you preach.
ReplyDeleteListen to yourself Dog.
You are the one that is the ayatollah.
Geez...what's next...bashing the Salvation Army for ringing that stinking bell at Christmas time.
Go rain on somebody else's parade...you have helped the devil long enough now.
Nor should there be obscenity, foolish talk or coarse joking, which are out of place, but rather thanksgiving.
ReplyDeleteEph 5:4
This whole Blog article is a LIE!
ReplyDeleteEd Young Jr. did not acquire a Church...they MERGED with a Church.
Ed and the Pastor of Friend Church have been life long friends and had been praying about this for a long time.
We are Better Together.
Unfortunately, some in the Body of Christ, are BITTER TOGETHER.
PLEASE STOP BEING A CANCER ON THE BODY OF CHRIST. YOU NEED SOME CHEMO ON YOUR HEART.
Merging with Ed Young equates to an acquisition by Ed in my view. Another outlet for Ed to sell his wares and market his brand of pseudo-Christianity. Another market in which he can sell his tithing baloney.
ReplyDeleteam surprised that Baptists have not asked/canvassed/lobbied the Government to collect the payroll tax of 10% as the Germans are doing (it is only 9% for the Germans)."
ReplyDeleteAre you serious? the government would keep 80% of the 10% they collected for the church. The greedy pastors and even most pew sitters are well aware the government is much more greedy.
"in my view".
ReplyDeleteThat's the problem Watchdog.
All of this is "in your view" not in God's view.
You have a lot of explaining to do before God one day on why you chose to lie, hate, slander, and ridicule God's Pastors.
"In my view", I don't want to be standing in your shoes before the King.
It ain't going to be pretty.
The ones who will be xplainin before God, prior to possible time below, are the pastors who lie in the pulpit, live like kings, and tell people that's because God chose them.
ReplyDeleteTithing as preached in megas is heresy and a sin, meant to line the pocket and enhance the power of the pastor. The bible teaches more against economic sin than against any other, and taking financial advantage of the flock is smack dab contrabiblical.
The troll is losing it big time. Do you really think your shoes are better to stand in than anyone else’s?
ReplyDeleteIt is only a matter of time before Ed Young or Perry Noble will release a video along the PSY Gangnam Style.
ReplyDeleteHas anyone noticed how mega pastors hire their wives and children in the churches they pastor and at very high levels of income over $100,000. That does not occur in the real corporate world. What is wrong with this? Anyone want to take a stab at it?
ReplyDeleteI have been a Christian now for over 30 years. I thought I had seen it all in Church until my Pastor brought a bed on stage and talked about having sex with his wife.
ReplyDeleteWhat the h___ is going on?
If I wanted to watch porn, I would do it at my house?
This stuff got my 15 year old boy all whipped up.
The Pastor needs to get off those little blue pills and get in the bible more.
Thank God for Pastors that are culturally relevant.
ReplyDelete1 Chron. 12:32 speaking of the sons of Issachar:
From the tribe of Issachar, there were 200 leaders of the tribe with their relatives. All these men understood the signs of the times and knew the best course for Israel to take.
"They understood the signs of the times".
If it took tight pants to get people in heaven, Jesus would have worn tight pants.
If it took rock bands and high definition video to win this world, then Jesus would be on plasma in Jerusalem.
"they (Jesus) understood the signs of the times."
Do YOU?
"Ed Young Jr. did not acquire a Church...they MERGED with a Church."
ReplyDeleteOh please. In October 2012, Fellowship Church announced that it had partnered with Friend Church in Columbia, SC, which would then become converted into a Fellowship Church satellite campus.
Enough said. Bookstore will stock mostly Ed Young media and tithes will be sent to Grapevine. Pastor at Friend Church will be on the payroll of Fellowship Church. It's become a McFellowship Church.
"PLEASE STOP BEING A CANCER ON THE BODY OF CHRIST. YOU NEED SOME CHEMO ON YOUR HEART."
ReplyDeleteThe TROLL is all heart and no brain. In other words, he doesn't think about issues, he has feelings about them. And feelings have no IQ.
COUNTDOWN: 69 days
ReplyDeleteThat's when we will find out if the TROLL's prayers are in God's will or not.
It's very lopsided when people keep hearing they should tithe, but the Church doesn't say what, biblically, the church should do with the tithe - and they don't invite people to hold them accountable to it.
ReplyDeleteGuess what's next Dog? Fellowship London. I'm tellin you, this is franchise church, corporate fashion, all in way that simply puts Ed's face and books in a wider place (to the exclusion of all other writers) and paves the way for Ed/Lisa to private jet all over the world and have the business (church) pay for it.
ReplyDeleteFC is opening 7 new churches all over the world in either fashion or fishing centers. Hmmmm.
This blog is dying before our eyes.
ReplyDeleteGod gives and God takes away.
He is taking away this poison and will put it where the sun don't shine.
Thank God for His ability to protect His servants.
RIP Blog...You tried to take our church down but the Devil is a liar.
I am amazed by this site.
ReplyDeleteI heard about this from a Pastor who was teaching on last day apostasy.
He taught us that in the last days there would be mockers and haters.
This blog is proof that we are in the last days.
I didn't realize that Christians could be so cruel until I read this jihab material.
"I heard about this from a Pastor who was teaching on last day apostasy."
ReplyDeleteYeah, we've heard that lie before TROLL. How many anons are you posting under and on both sides of the issue.
We can still tell its you because of your silly immature rantings.
Get out of the basement and get a job!
When you go to Wal-Mart you see on the wall it says "manager" with a name and picture. That means somebody in that store is in charge of somebody else's stuff. What would happen if that manager just decided one Monday morning that he wasn't going to open, and just started hauling off the stuff? Well, it wouldn't take Sam Walton long to show up in his green pick-up, if he were living, and put a stop to that. Why? It's not the manager's stuff. You see he's managing Wal-Mart, he doesn't own Wal-Mart.
ReplyDeleteIn the 12th chapter of Luke, verse 35, it's about the evil servant. I found God's judgment came upon the one set in charge of God's business. And the Greek word there is the word "servant". It means manager or steward and God said "I'm bringing judgment to this one because he didn't handle my affairs correctly. I mean this was mine, I left you in charge and you blew it."
Well, let me show it to you again. In the 16th chapter of the same book, is the parable of the unjust steward. He said to his disciples, "He who is faithful in a little, is faithful also in much. And he who is unfaithful in a little, is unfaithful also in much."
If I give you $1000 this week and $100 belongs to God, it's a sacred thing, and if you don't take care of that as a manager or as a steward, what makes you think that God will trust you with something eternal? He won't.
And it goes on, God's judgment against the one's in charge of His money. 1 Corinthians, Chapter 4 - verse 2 says, "Moreover it is required"...that word required kind of burns in my spirit..."of stewards"...that's the same word we've been using ...or manager, ....it is required "that they have been found faithful."
Now how many of you know that when God says required, it is not a
suggestion. They're not the 10 suggestions. Theyre call Commandments. So God wants you to get hold of something that will set you free. I am totally convinced that when church members begin to understand their relationship with the money that God has put in their hands, revival is going to break out. I can tell you it really will. The move of God is coming.
I'm curious, how do those of you who do not support tithing propose we fund the efforts of the local church? I attend a church that has about 2000 people attending in four services. Our lead pastor makes $27,ooo/year, so he is not "fleecing us".
ReplyDeleteWe have a limited number of staff and associate pastors who are paid. Volunteers fill in the gaps.
This is not a combative statement, just one of genuine curiousity.
Someone may be tempted to suggest that our pastors work a part-time job, but I can assure you that the amount of time they devote to the conduct of their jobs would not allow for that.
I look forward to a civil conversation on this topic.
I say lock em in a steel cage with no holds barred. The man who walks out can keep his church and continue to preach tithing. The loser must have his head shaven, and close down his version of God's work. Afterall, the one who "tithes" the most should win given that is what they preach in the pulpit-right? IE the more you give the more God blesses
ReplyDeleteBill
"I'm curious, how do those of you who do not support tithing propose we fund the efforts of the local church?"
ReplyDeleteThe exact same way they did in the first century church.
How were churches funded in the first century? If your income depended on that mode of compensation how secure would you feel?
ReplyDeleteCulturally, I think we have lost a lot of integrity in general. I don't know the answer to my question above, but if it relied on the generosity of the average Joe, I don't know that any churches would thrive.
"How were churches funded in the first century? If your income depended on that mode of compensation how secure would you feel?"
ReplyDeleteHow well did it work for the first century church?
I find that the Biblical model works best.
Someone may be tempted to suggest that our pastors work a part-time job, but I can assure you that the amount of time they devote to the conduct of their jobs would not allow for that.
ReplyDeleteMark, is it possible that the pastors are taking on more responsibilities and activities than necessary or required by that position?
Assuming burdens that could/should be left to the body of Christ could very well lead to burnout as well as denying the opportunity for mutual caring for one another among believers.
Just wondering...
"Mark, is it possible that the pastors are taking on more responsibilities and activities than necessary or required by that position?"
ReplyDeleteAccording to a poll taken not long ago, 86% of pastors agree that they are trying to do too much and feel burned out.
Again, this is not how things worked in the first century church.
I was wondering what happened to the Columbia satellite location. It is no longer listed on the Fellowship Church site as a campus and it was taken off of the Seven campaign. I guess it was no longer financially feasible.
ReplyDeleteWhat happeded to the South Carolina campus?
ReplyDeleteHello Everybody,
ReplyDeleteMy name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.